The Silent Treatment

26 Nov


I know, you don’t even want to talk about this one. Seems like every marriage endures it share of these at times and they’re not always bad things. That said, what you fail to say can be just as destructive to your marriage as what you do say. Stoic silence is a emotional tool men and women both use in marriage all too often for the wrong reasons, but there are good reasons to use it.

I’ll explain. To start, I think we can all agree that when we say things in anger we tend to say exactly what me mean at that moment in the most destructive possible way. What’s worse is that a simple “I’m Sorry”, even a heartfelt one does not undo the damage. Angry words are like spikes nailed into a wooden plank. “I’m Sorry” can remove the spike, but the hole in the wood remains. Think about this for a moment, the logical conclusion is that when you’re angry it is better to say nothing at all until you have had a bit to process your anger and can address the issue in a more controlled manner and choose your words carefully.

This does not mean that you should wait forever – many issues just get worse as time passes and the silent treatment itself can wound deeply. Long term the silent treatment induces a feeling of doubt about you and your commitment to the relationship. Your wife cannot read your mind, but she can read you moods and body language. She will know there is something wrong, and without her understanding what it is you are placing a tremendous emotional burden on her. Her job is to help you either resolve or deal with whatever is bothering you and by keeping it from her you are preventing her from doing so. It helps to stop and remember this key thing – through the Catholic sacrament of marriage you become one flesh and what wounds one of you wounds both, and what helps one of you helps both of you.

The most dangerous use is when you are angry at your spouse. Husbands can be a moody lot – particularly when they’re not getting the attention, affection, sex, respect, or acknowledgment they think they deserve. I speak from personal experience here. Being silent about it does not give your wife a chance to fix it, and silence is only appropriate until you’ve figured out how to tell her what is bothering you without blaming her or making her the focus. 99% of the time these are caused by not communicating your wants and needs rather than an attempt by your wife to harm you emotionally – much less damage your relationship. I’ve discovered that if both spouses would do a better job of both listening, and observing the cues, most of these issues can be avoided. Where that is not enough, or your when spouse is missing an important cue you need to fill them in and explain why you’re feeling that way. Instead, we often let insecurity and doubt cloud our judgement and we start thinking selfishly and defensively. Your spouse is not an adversary, any more than you arm or leg is, do not treat them like one.

I’ll use sex as a nice inflammatory example. Husbands can get sullen quickly over a lack thereof, without giving a thought to the fact that their wife could be suffering from an embarrassing female problem like a yeast infection, be exhausted physically and mentally from a particularly hard couple of days, be sick and hiding it while trying to muddle through, stricken with depression, or feeling neglected and/or unattractive herself. You keep silent, but as the days pass you get more and more sullen and distant until by the time the original (usually) temporary condition is gone – you’re both in a “silent treatment” death spiral and miles apart emotionally. It’s not really the lack of sex you’re angry about, it’s a sense of rejection you’re taking personally. The funny thing is that it’s often not about you at all. If you don’t know what is broken you can’t do anything to fix it – even if the fix is just to be there and hold her and for moral support.

It all comes down to honest communication. Don’t keep things from your spouse, that way you can address issues when they’re molehills and before they become mountains. Encourage her not to keep things from you by being a good listener and never being judgmental – if she fears your reaction then she will hide things (just as you will if you fear hers). This is a pernicious evil you have to address head-on and the trust required on both sides will take time to build, but it’s worth it.

I’d like to leave you with a parting thought – Remember that you have vowed yourself to serving her. When you get mad about things like attention, affection, sex, respect, or acknowledgment then you are not serving her. You are serving yourself, and breaking your vows at the same time. This applies to both spouses equally. If you serve her above yourself and she does the same for you then by making yourself last you will unintentionally be first, she will experience the same from you and the marriage will begin to bloom. Funny how Christ’s words from the beatitudes ring true – especially in marriage.


4 Responses to “The Silent Treatment”

  1. prayingforoneday November 26, 2013 at 2:32 am #

    The wife is ALWAYS right Colin, man code dictated this 100 years ago..

    Joking aside, BRILLIANT WRITING MATE. Relationships are hard work. Sometimes we all hit that bump in the road. Being best friends with your partner helps. I am with Dawn, we are best friends, we share all and trust 100%. Sadly many marriages are not so good. We all know couples where really there is no love, just 2 people together our of habit. I see it all over. People ask Dawn and I all the time “Why are you not Married” and I always reply with “We are happier than you why you asking me this shit” Seriously. I told you Colin, but I will tell others, I was Catholic (Legally still am I am told) Many couples in my Mums side are Catholic, my mum has 9 brothers and sisters. So I get it in the ear a LOT from family.. Couples who argue like cat and dog and you can tell hate each other, asking me why I am not married 😀 Can you feel the irony?

    Good blog and good points. What is the perfect balance, does Sorry mean sorry to one or the other? Can we forgive, can we forget when bad things happen?

    I guess it depends on the couple. I am in life to be Happy, nothing more, nothing less. Maybe I will marry Dawn one day. But this second, we have made the commitment to each other. We are happy. Much of what you say in your blog I can’t relate to as I have no been through it. I am with a woman/best friend I never argue with..

    But looking out into the big bad old world, I can see why you blogged this.
    Very good blog Colin.



  2. socialawareness2013 November 26, 2013 at 9:49 am #

    Reblogged this on Social Awareness.


  3. Brenda Barnett Asong February 28, 2019 at 7:52 am #

    Why do my husband have to be silent to me when I have not done anything wrong.? We are apart but Saturday we will be together. I said good morning to him he was online.but he didn’t respond back to me and it makes me think I done something wrong.



  1. The Silent Treatment | The Fickle Heartbeat - August 21, 2014

    […] Shared by Colin Corcoran Jr. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: